Monday, 22 June 2015

What's in the Name?

In the past Gandharva Chitrangada fought and killed Shantanuputra Chitrangada because both of them didn’t want to share the name. Paundraka Vasudeva was killed by Krishna Vasudeva. Dasharathi Rama confronted Parashu Rama. 

In the Kurukshetra war fought between thousands of warriors. With 100 Kauravas and so many princes and warriors, many must have shared the names and confusion must have occurred, often.

Sahadeva Pandava and Sahadeva the king of Magadha both fought for Pandavas and latter was killed by Drona,

Jayatsena was prince of Magadha, killed by Abhimanyu, Jayatsena Kaurava was killed by Bhima.

Alamvusha Rakshasa son of Rishyasringa was killed by Ghatotkacha in Dronaparva and Alamvusha Rakshasa son of Jatasura also was killed by him in Karna Parva.

There were three pairs of “Vinda and Anuvinda”. First pair being sons of Gandhari killed by Bhima, second pair was from Avanti, killed by Arjuna and third pair of Kekaya princes killed by Satyaki.

Vrihadvala prince of Gandhara was killed by Arjuna’s son Eravan and Vrihadvala king of Kosala by Abhimanyu.

Name Chitrasena seems to be very popular. In Drona Parva (Ch 134) Kaurava prince Chitrasena was killed by Bhima (still in Ch 166 he fights and gets defeated by Shatanika). In Karna Parva Chitrasena (Ch 6) of sea coast was killed by Samudrasen and Abhira King Chitrasena was slain by Shrutakarma (Ch 14). Panchala warrior Chitrasena (Ch 48) was killed by Karna and Karna’s brother Chitrasena by Yudhamanyu (Ch 83). In Shalya Parva (Ch 10) Nakula dispatches Karna’s son Chitrasena to Yama’s abode.

Even the epic has at times confused. Shatanika son of Nakula was killed by Ashvatthama on 18th night. But Shatanika Virata’s brother was killed by Bhishma (6/119) by Drona (7/210 and by Shalya (7/165) too!

Gandhari had 100 sons and their names appear with some difference at different places in Mahabharata. Some of the names are Bhimaratha, Bhimabala, Bhimavikrama and Bhimavega. In Bhishma Parva (Ch 64), names of Kauravas killed by Bhima on fourth day include Bhimaratha and Bhima!!

Fortunately, no one shared the names of bows, Gandiva and Vijaya used in the war, neither conches of Pandavas- Panchajanya, Ananta-Vijaya, Poundra-Khadga, Devadatta, Sughosha and Mani-pushpaka. But out of four horses Shaibya, Sugreeva, Meghapushpa and Balaahaka of Krishna’s chariot, name Shaibya is shared by warrior from Pandava side. Supratik was famous elephant of Bhagadatta killed by Arjuna. But Bhima discovered and killed elephant named Ashvatthama and managed to confuse Drona. To confirm the rumor about the death of his son Ashvatthama, Drona asked Yudhishthira if Ashvatthama has really been killed and he got the reply “Ashwathama had died but he was not sure whether it was a human or an elephant- Ashvatthama Hatahatah, naro va Kunjaro va”, Last half of the sentence could not be heard by Drona, which enabled Dhrishtadyumna to behead Drona.

There must be many more names shared by the warriors. With so many names Mahabharata doesn’t give name of son of Duhshasana who had slain Abhimanyu. Durmarshana killed in Shalyaparva by Bhima was son of Gandhari and not her grandson.

Saturday, 20 June 2015

Departure of Heroes of Kuru and Yadu Dynesties

Character
How the end came
Comment
Pratipa
Vanaprastha with wife Sunanda
Devapi-leprosy abdicated
Bahlika-ruled maternal uncle’s Balkha-Somadatta-Bhurishrava, Bhuri, Shala
Shantanu
Died while ruling the kingdom

Ganga
Left Shantanu after birth of Devavrata Bhishma
Deathless Goddess

Satyavati
After the death of Pandu went to forest with Ambika and Ambalika

Bhishma
Injured by Shikhandi+Arjuna-Death by choice

Vyasa
Chiranjivi

Chitrangada
Killed by Chitrangada Gandharva

Vichitravirya
Died of Raja-yakshma

Ambika-Mother of Dhritarashtra
After the death of Pandu went to forest
Amba-self immolated
Next birth Shikhandi-killed by Ashvatthama
Ambalika/Kausalya-Mother of Pandu
After the death of Pandu went to forest
Pandu
Due to a curse, died when tried to be intimate with wife Madri

Madri
Committed Sati with Pandu

Kunti
15 years after war vanaprastha ashrama. The three perished in forest fire.
Dhritarashtra sent back Sanjaya.


Vidura looked at Yudhishthira deeply and left his body.

Dhritarashtra
Gavalganaputra Sanjaya
Survived forestfire
Gandhari
Yuyutsu’s mother Sughada
No further mention
Vidura (Parishrami + Vyasa Putra)
Vidura’s wife Sulabha
No further mention.
Any sons?
Kauravas
All hundred Killed by Bhima
Yuyutsu survived
Yuyutsu was care taker of Parikshita/ Indraprastha
Kaurava wives
No further mention

Kaurava Sons & Grandsons
All killed by sons of Pandavas

Duhshala
Remained in Sindhu-Sauvira

Jayadratha
Killed by Arjuna

Son of Duhshala- Suradha
Dies of grief when Arjuna comes along with Ashvamegha horse.  His minor son made king
Karna
Killed by Arjuna
Radha-Adhiratha survived
Nurtured Vrishaketu
Karna’s Brothers killed in the war
Karna’s Wives
Vrushali and Supriya
Vrushali Committed  Sati
Supriya/Padmavati  perhaps nurtured Vrishaketu
Karna’s Nine Sons

Eight of them-Vrishasens, Chitrasena, satyasena, Sushena, Shatrumjaya, Dvipata, Banasena, Prasena Killed by Arjuna, Bhima, Satyaki, Nakula

Vrishaketu survived Nurtured by Arjuna, killed by Babhruvahana, revived by Ulupi and became Anga King
Pandavas and Draupadi
Swargarohana

Draupadeyas
Killed by Ashvatthama
Prativindhya, Sutasoma, Shrutakirti, Shatanika and Shrutakarma
Other wives and sons of Pandavas
Yudhisthira+Saivya Devika-Yaudheya, Bhima+Kashi Valandhara-Sarvaga, Nakula+Chedi Karenumati-Niramitra, Sahadeva+Madra Vijaya-Suhotra, Manipura princess Chitrangada and son Babhruvahana appear in Ashvamedha Parva. In Jaimineya Ashvedhaparva Arjuna also marries queen of Naripura-Parimala also Jammu’s Dogra princes of Babour gave birth to Babhruvahana II—Stayed in their fathers houses. No further mention
Abhimanyu
Killed by Daushasani+6

Subhadra
Remained with Parikshita



Uttara

Vatsala

Parikshita
Died of Takshaka bite due to curse
Wife Madravati/Iravati (daughter of Uttar)
Janmejaya
Abdicated due to differences with Vaishampayana. Hastinapura ruled by his descendants and Indraprastha by the descendents of his brother Kakshasena
Wife Vapushtama
Son Shatanika or Ashvameghadatta
Hidimbi
Remained at Hidimbavat

Ghatotkacha
Killed by Karna

Anjanaparva
Killed by Ashvathhama

Meghavarna
Son of Ghatotkacha helped Pandva for Ashvamedha Yadnya rules Hidimbavat lives with mother Ahilavati/Maurvi Nagakanya
Not in Vyasa Mahabharata but in Jaimini’s Ashvamedha Parva
Barbareeka
Son of Ghatotkacha, gives head to Lord Krishna before the war
Ulupi
Remained in Naga capital close to Manipura

Eravana
Killed by Rakshasa Alambusha

Chitrangada
Remained at Manipura with son Babhruvahana as king

Vasudeva-Devaki-Rohini
Vasudeva died of grief when Krishna left for Vaikuntha and Devaki, Rohini and other wives committed Sati

Balarama
Meditated and left for Vaikuntha (Adi Shesha Ananta departed his body from his mouth)

Revati wife of Balarama
Committed Sati

Sons of Balarama
Nishatha, Ulmuka were killed inYadavi

Yogamaya

Nanda-Yashoda’s daughter, Exchanged for Krishna, Kansa tried to kill her but escapes.

Krishna
Meditated and left for Vaikuntha (hit by an arrow of hunter Jara)

Rukmini
Committed Sati along with Jambavati, princes of Gandhara, Shaivya (Mitravinda-Avanti), Haimaavati

Other wives of Krishna

Satyabhama and (Nagnajiti Kosala, Kalindi-Yamuna, Bhadra-Kekaya, Lakshmana-Madra, Satya, Rohini) entered the forest, to practice of penances.
According to Bhagavata  Krishna’s wives, daughter-in-laws, etc committed Sati
Radha
Name doesn’t appear in Mahabharata, Harivansha, Bhagavata & Vishnu Purana
Nanda and Yashoda: Met Krishna and Balarama during solar eclips at Kurukshetra (before Subhadra-haran according to Bhagavata), No further mention
Krishna’s sons, grandsons, friends cousins
All except Vajra, Killed each other at Prabhasa (Somanatha). Curse of Rishi and Gandhari

Vajra (nabha) son of Aniruddha
Established at Indraprastha by Arjuna according to Mahabharata. At Mathura/Vraja according to Bhagavata

Uddhava
Left for pilgrimage

Vrishni Satyaki’s son
Yuyudhani
Established on the bank of Saraswati

Bhoja Kritavarma’s son Bali
Established at Marttikavat

Samba’s son Ushneek
Established at Kashyapur (near Multan)

Dwarika
Established by Sri Krishna after leaving Mathura. Submerged in Sea after Yadavi

Hastinapura
Kuru capital. Ruled by descendants of Kuru, Capital shifted further east to Kaushambi due to repeated Gangetic floods around 600 BC. Kurus further divided into Kuru Vatsa of Kaushambi and of Mathura

Indraprastha or Khandavaprastha
Pandava established capital, then lost it in the game of dice. For a while with Yuyutsu or Vajra then Kuru descendants took over again



Tuesday, 16 June 2015

Confusion about the names of Draupadeyas

Empress Draupadi is one of the most dominating ladies of Mahbharata. But unfortunately hers sons have little role to play in the epic. All of them were slain by Ashvatthama on the night of 18th day of war along with remaining warriors. There is confusion about the names of her sons. Her sons of Yudhishthira, Bhima and Nakula are Prativindhya, Sutasoma and Shatanika but name of Arjuna’s son is either Shrutakirti or Shrutakarman and name of Sahadeva’s son Shrutasena and Shrutakarman as referred in Adiparva and Aranyaparva of Mahabharata. English Translation by K.M.Ganguli and BORI’s critical version do not differ.

K.M.Ganguli
Mbh.1.63.3184
Mbh.1.67.3547

Mbh.1.95.5341
Mbh.3.12.674
Mbh 10.8
10/8
Mbh.1.223.10874
Mbh.3.233.11829

BORI
1/57/102

1/90/82
3/13/65
1/213/72
3/224/10
Yudhishthir
Pritivindhya
Prativindhya
Prativindhya
Bhima
Sutasoma
Sutasoma
Sutasoma
Arjuna
S(h)rutakirti
S(h)rutakirti
S(h)rutakarman
Nakula
S(h)atanika
S(h)atanika
S(h)atanika
Sahadeva
S(h)rutasena
S(h)rutakarman
S(h)rutasena

The contradiction can only be resolved in their tragic death at the hand of Ashvatthama in Sauptika Parva. Name Shrutasena doesn’t appear indicating Arjuna’s son was Shrutakirti and Sahadeva’s son Shrutakarman.